How to Follow the Spirit’s Direction in the Midst of a Capital Campaign

Jim Pace • November 9, 2026

Share this article

A church capital campaign asks people to make significant decisions about money, ministry, and

the future. Following the Spirit’s direction means bringing those decisions before God together,

listening honestly, setting aside the fear and worry that can often accompany capital campaigns,

and remaining willing to change course if need be at the right time.

Prayer should influence the campaign’s decisions and relationships from beginning to end.


• Begin with the ministry God is calling you to serve

Before asking how much you as a church can raise, ask what the proposed project will make possible.

Who will be served? What ministry is constrained today? Why is this the appropriate response? Name

the ministry purpose clearly enough that your leaders can evaluate other ways of fulfilling it. This is not to

avoid the capital campaign, but to test its requirement.


“A building can support a calling, but ownership or expansion does not establish that calling.”


• Seek wisdom together

James 1:5 invites believers facing trials (which raising large amounts of money can sometimes feel like)

to ask God for wisdom. That invitation encourages dependence rather than the expectation that a leader

must already have every answer. In Acts 15, the church addresses a major theological dispute through

testimony, discussion, and attention to Scripture. Its setting differs from a campaign, but it offers a

helpful picture of communal discernment: leaders listen before reaching a conclusion. This doesn’t mean

the leader with the strongest sense the project (with the capital campaign) is the way to go needs to

release that clarity; they just need to hold that clarity in community and allow other voices to speak into

it. In my 25 years as a pastor, I would often notice things a bit sooner than the rest of my pastoral team,

but as I submitted what I was seeing to the group, inevitably the plan became stronger.


• Make room for an honest answer

Ask leaders, staff, donors, and other attenders what they see, including those who are uncertain. A

readiness study can reveal questions that enthusiasm has overlooked. Financial information and

congregational feedback help inform discernment; neither automatically announces God’s will. Explain

what remains undecided, and avoid using language such as ‘God told us’ to close a conversation that still

needs to happen.


• Let prayer change the plan

Build listening and prayer into the leadership team’s regular work. Before an important decision, identify the question, review the available information, and ask what needs further examination. After praying, record the decision, the reasons, and when to revisit it. A lender’s deadline or an available property matters, but urgency alone should not determine the church’s response.


• Invite generosity with freedom

Paul’s teaching in 2 Corinthians 9:7 connects giving with a willing response rather than compulsion. In a

campaign, communicate the need and make clear invitations, while allowing people to discern their

participation. A smaller gift, a request for time, or an inability to give does not establish someone’s level

of faith. Protect donor confidentiality and welcome questions without treating them as obstacles. In my

experience, this is one of the most common pitfalls a church can fall into in the midst of a capital

campaign. The leaders of the campaign can start to feel that if someone has not responded in a timely

manner, that those people are against them! It is very natural to want to feel this way, I just try to remind

those leaders that they have likely done the exact same thing in the past, I know I have!


• Notice what is happening among you

Galatians 5:22–23 names the fruit of the Spirit in the life of believers. It does not provide a campaign

scorecard, but it gives leaders a searching lens: Are our practices expressing patience, kindness, PEACE,

faithfulness, and self-control? Track pledges and cash carefully while also noticing whether trust is

deepening, responsibilities are shared, and people are learning to serve together.


Questions for your leadership team

— What are we asking the Spirit to show us beyond how to reach the financial goal?

— Whose perspective have we not heard?

— What evidence would cause us to revise our approach?


Choose one upcoming decision and practice this kind of listening together.


A Place to Begin: Discerning Partners helps churches connect campaign strategy with shared spiritual discernment. To discuss your church’s next step, contact info@discerningpartners.com.


Scripture for further reading: James 1:5 • Acts 15:1–29 • 2 Corinthians 9:7 • Galatians 5:22–23

Recent Posts

By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Oh this was a big one for me and I did not even realize it for a few years! When I (finally) heard what the Spirit was telling me, I realized that I had been trying to build our church as proof that I was good enough!
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Prayer and planning belong in the same conversation. A church needs reliable costs, clear responsibilities, and a workable schedule.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
A campaign goal should connect a meaningful ministry purpose with a credible path to funding. It should be ambitious enough to invite thoughtful generosity and sufficiently grounded that leaders can explain the assumptions.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
I cannot stress this enough: considering or running a capital campaign will bring questions and concerns! Questions about a campaign can reveal confusion, practical problems, or a genuine disagreement about priorities.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
The first campaign decision is whether a campaign is the right next step! A compelling opportunity deserves careful consideration, but excitement, a building becoming available, or a few encouraging donor conversations should begin a process of discernment rather than end it.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Far and away, this is one of the biggest concerns (after, “Can we raise this much?”) that I hear from pastors and church leaders about Capital Campaigns! As someone who served on a church staff and pastoral team for 25 years, I can say I get it.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Now this is the situation that most church leaders involved with capital campaigns think about when they wake up in the middle of the night! When campaign giving trails the goal, leaders need an honest picture and a calm response.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Campaign totals matter because real ministry commitments depend on them. Yet they tell only part of the story.
By Jim Pace • September 14, 2026
Every dollar spent on campaign counsel is a dollar that isn’t going into the project itself. The real question isn’t what a consultant costs — it’s what that cost will do to what you’re ultimately able to build.
By Jim Pace • September 14, 2026
The short answer? No. But having been a pastor for 25 years, I get why the question is asked — I’ve asked it myself.
Show More