How Can Church Leaders Distinguish God’s Direction from Their Own Ambition?
Oh this was a big one for me and I did not even realize it for a few years! When I (finally) heard what
the Spirit was telling me, I realized that I had been trying to build our church as proof that I was
good enough!
So, I know of what I speak when I say, a pastor can sincerely love a church and still become deeply
attached to a particular project. The question is how leaders will examine that attachment together.
Discernment requires humility, trusted relationships, and a willingness to hear something other than the
answer we hope to receive.
• Be honest about what the project represents
Ask what feels personally important about this campaign. It may represent room for ministry, relief from
years of limitations, or a long-held dream. It may also become entangled with comparison, reputation, or
the desire to leave a legacy. Mixed motives call for honest examination rather than a quick verdict that
the entire vision is either pure or misguided. Now also please hear this: If that were the case, nothing
would ever get done! The balance is understanding we can be driven by all kinds of motives:
accomplishment, not wanting to change, fear, ego... so many things, and each of us is driven by different
ones. We have a good approach when those analyzing the project and potential capital campaign are
aware of their emotional defaults, in prayerful discernment with trusted people that have different
defaults, and everyone is seeking the direction of the Lord, not the thing that makes them happiest.
“The Spirit does not require that we as church leaders 'get it right' before He begins to move.”
• Let Scripture examine the manner of leadership
Philippians 2:3–4 directs believers away from selfish ambition and toward concern for others. Applied to
a campaign, that teaching invites leaders to ask whose needs the project serves and whose burdens it
creates. James 3:17 describes wisdom from above in terms that include peace, gentleness, and openness
to reason. These are searching questions about how we lead, not a formula for proving a project is
divinely endorsed.
• Invite people who can disagree with you
Choose trusted voices who understand the ministry and are not dependent on pleasing the senior leader.
Ask them to identify what feels compelling and what remains untested. A staff meeting may not provide
the same freedom as a confidential conversation. Make it clear that questioning the scope, timing, or
cost will not jeopardize someone’s place in the church.
• Test your willingness to release the preferred outcome
Consider a concrete alternative: a smaller renovation, a later launch, or ministry in a different location.
Can you discuss its merits without feeling that your calling is under attack? Emotional difficulty does not
settle the spiritual question. It can, however, reveal where you need prayer, rest, or a trusted conversation
before making another consequential decision.
• Separate conviction from control
Leaders can state a conviction clearly while acknowledging that it needs to be tested. Explain why you
believe the project serves the church’s mission and what information remains incomplete. Avoid claiming
spiritual certainty to bypass appropriate governance. The board’s responsibility is meaningful only if it
can evaluate, revise, or decline the proposal through the church’s established process.
• Keep evaluating after the campaign begins
Attachment can grow as time, money, and public expectations accumulate. Set review points to examine
the project’s purpose, costs, funding, and effect on people. Psalm 139:23–24 gives language for inviting
God’s examination and guidance. A regular willingness to be searched is more useful than assuming that
discernment ended when leaders first approved the vision.
Questions for your leadership team
— What criticism is hardest for us to hear?
— Who has permission to challenge our assumptions?
— What would we willingly change if better information emerged?
Invite each leader to name one attachment privately before discussing the project’s next major decision
together.
Continue the Conversation: Discerning Partners helps church leaders examine
campaign decisions with candor and care. Contact info@discerningpartners.com.
Scripture for further reading: Philippians 2:3–4 • James 3:17 • Psalm 139:23–24
Recent Posts










