How Does a Church Discern Whether to Begin a Capital Campaign?

Jim Pace • November 9, 2026

Share this article

The first campaign decision is whether a campaign is the right next step! A compelling opportunity

deserves careful consideration, but excitement, a building becoming available, or a few

encouraging donor conversations should begin a process of discernment rather than end it.

During my 25 years in ministry and as a pastor I can say allowing the discernment process to unfold in

the Spirit’s timing was one of the harder things I needed to learn to submit to!


• Describe the need before choosing the solution

Write a short explanation of the ministry need without naming the proposed building or construction

project. Who needs to be served, and what prevents the church from serving them well today? Then

compare possible responses. Renovation, shared space, a smaller project, or a different schedule may

address the need. Considering alternatives helps leaders evaluate a proposal on its ministry merits. This

can feel like a time where you really might want to put your finger on the scale a bit to move the

conversation forward. Resist this! Give honest analyses of the options and trust your other leaders to

genuinely seek the Spirit along the way.


• Ask for wisdom and invite counsel

James 1:5 encourages asking God for wisdom. Proverbs 15:22 highlights the value of counsel. Together,

these passages support a posture of dependence and openness; they do not promise that every planning

meeting will produce certainty. Invite people with financial, ministry, and congregational perspectives.

Give them permission to name concerns without being treated as opponents of the vision.


• Look for readiness in several places

Examine leadership alignment, congregational understanding, financial health, donor relationships, and

the capacity to carry a campaign. A feasibility or readiness study can bring these perspectives together.

Outside funding deserves its own examination: an interested foundation is a relationship to develop, not a

confirmed gift. Identify eligibility, likely timing, restrictions, and what remains unknown before relying on

that funding.


• Count the continuing cost

In Luke 14:28–33, Jesus uses building and military examples to teach about the cost of discipleship.

Without reducing that teaching to a budgeting lesson, leaders can recognize the importance of facing

commitments honestly. Consider ongoing utilities, maintenance, staffing, debt service, and ministry

expenses alongside construction costs. A successful purchase can still create an unsustainable operating

burden.


• Choose a next step you can explain

The decision need not be an immediate yes or no to the entire campaign. Leaders might approve a

study, commission better cost estimates, or spend a season listening. Record what has been authorized

and what has not. If the church requires a congregational vote, honor that process and explain which

preliminary work serves the decision rather than assumes its outcome.


• Know what would make you wait

Before momentum builds, identify conditions that warrant a pause: unresolved leadership conflict,

uncertain property rights, unreliable project costs, or a funding schedule that cannot meet required

payments. Name the work to complete, who will do it, and when the decision will return for consideration.


“Waiting can be a responsible response, but postponement also needs a purpose.”


Questions for your leadership team

— Can we describe the ministry need clearly?

— What have we learned from people outside the planning group?

— Which uncertainties must be resolved before inviting commitments?


At your next meeting, agree on the evidence needed for the next decision and assign responsibility for

gathering it.


Continue the Conversation: For help assessing whether your church is ready for a capital campaign, contact Discerning Partners at info@discerningpartners.com.


Scripture for further reading: James 1:5 • Proverbs 15:22 • Luke 14:28–33

Recent Posts

By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Oh this was a big one for me and I did not even realize it for a few years! When I (finally) heard what the Spirit was telling me, I realized that I had been trying to build our church as proof that I was good enough!
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Prayer and planning belong in the same conversation. A church needs reliable costs, clear responsibilities, and a workable schedule.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
A church capital campaign asks people to make significant decisions about money, ministry, and the future. Following the Spirit’s direction means bringing those decisions before God together, listening honestly, setting aside the fear and worry that can often accompany capital campaigns, and remaining willing to change course if need be at the right time.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
A campaign goal should connect a meaningful ministry purpose with a credible path to funding. It should be ambitious enough to invite thoughtful generosity and sufficiently grounded that leaders can explain the assumptions.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
I cannot stress this enough: considering or running a capital campaign will bring questions and concerns! Questions about a campaign can reveal confusion, practical problems, or a genuine disagreement about priorities.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Far and away, this is one of the biggest concerns (after, “Can we raise this much?”) that I hear from pastors and church leaders about Capital Campaigns! As someone who served on a church staff and pastoral team for 25 years, I can say I get it.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Now this is the situation that most church leaders involved with capital campaigns think about when they wake up in the middle of the night! When campaign giving trails the goal, leaders need an honest picture and a calm response.
By Jim Pace • November 9, 2026
Campaign totals matter because real ministry commitments depend on them. Yet they tell only part of the story.
By Jim Pace • September 14, 2026
Every dollar spent on campaign counsel is a dollar that isn’t going into the project itself. The real question isn’t what a consultant costs — it’s what that cost will do to what you’re ultimately able to build.
By Jim Pace • September 14, 2026
The short answer? No. But having been a pastor for 25 years, I get why the question is asked — I’ve asked it myself.
Show More